Access all our platforms from a single account.
Natural gas: Europe faces winter supply risks while US traders bet on lower prices
Key Points:
- European gas prices retreat: The Dutch TTF benchmark has fallen around 17% from last week's peak as hopes for a Middle East peace deal ease geopolitical risk premiums, although near-term supply constraints remain unresolved.
- Low storage increases winter risks: European inventories are just 74.3% full versus a five-year average near 90%, leaving the region vulnerable to colder weather and supply disruptions.
- LNG supply recovery will take time: Even a full reopening of the Strait of Hormuz would leave Europe facing several weeks of delayed deliveries and continued competition with Asia.
- US hedge funds bet on a mild winter: US Henry Hub futures trade below USD 3/MMBtu as speculative shorts reach their highest since 2020, raising the risk of a short squeeze if heating demand surprises.
European natural gas prices remain elevated amid persistent Middle East supply disruptions, low storage levels and uncertainty over winter demand. Meanwhile, US natural gas continues to trade below USD 3/MMBtu, with hedge funds building their largest bearish positions in years, partly on expectations that a strong El Niño will reduce heating demand. The divergence highlights the very different supply and demand dynamics facing the two markets.
The Dutch TTF benchmark which reached EUR 104 last week, its highest level since the 2022 European gas crisis triggered by the disruption to Russian pipeline supplies, has since declined by around 17% supported by speculation in the market that President Trump may seek to put the Middle East conflict behind him following the bruising Midterms election defeat. Apart from the all-important weather outlook, European gas traders as seen in the recent price action maintain a razor-sharp focus on developments in the Middle East, particularly the prospects for a negotiated settlement that could allow LNG shipments to resume through the Strait of Hormuz.
Europe has entered winter facing an estimated LNG supply shortfall equivalent to roughly 100 large carriers compared with recent years. Against this backdrop, European gas prices are likely to continue ebbing and flowing with crude oil, responding to headlines suggesting either progress towards a peace agreement or renewed escalation.
However, even if the Strait of Hormuz were to reopen fully tomorrow, it could still take several weeks before additional LNG cargoes reached European terminals. Restarting production and shipping operations may add further delays. Consequently, while a reopening could trigger an immediate decline as geopolitical risk premiums unwind, it would not resolve Europe's near-term physical supply challenges.
Low European inventories increase winter vulnerability
Europe enters the winter withdrawal season with storage facilities just 74.3% full, well below the five-year seasonal average near 90%. This leaves the region with a significantly smaller buffer against prolonged cold spells or unexpected supply disruptions. The vulnerability is compounded by the fact that gas withdrawn from storage typically covers less than 30% of Europe's winter consumption, leaving the region heavily dependent on continued pipeline imports and LNG deliveries to meet the remaining demand.
The coming months will therefore be critical, with European demand depending not only on temperatures but also on the frequency of Dunkelflaute episodes, when low wind and solar generation increase reliance on gas- and coal-fired power generation.
Meanwhile, Europe will have to compete with Asian buyers for available seaborne LNG supplies. With both Dutch TTF and Asian LNG prices trading near USD 30/MMBtu, the relative strength of winter demand across the two regions will help determine where flexible cargoes are directed.
US hedge funds build biggest gas short since 2020
Across the Atlantic, the picture is markedly different. US Henry Hub natural gas continues to trade below USD 3/MMBtu, supported by robust domestic production and expectations that a strong El Niño could reduce heating demand this winter.
In the reporting week to 27 October, managed money accounts increased their combined net short across the two main Henry Hub futures contracts traded on CME and ICE to the highest level since 2020. In the benchmark CME contract alone, leveraged accounts held a net short of approximately 205,000 contracts, equivalent to 2.05 trillion cubic feet of gas.
The bearish positioning reflects expectations of weaker heating demand, with US underground storage currently near 3.7 trillion cubic feet, broadly in line with the five-year seasonal average. However, the increasingly crowded short position also raises the risk of a sharp reversal should weather forecasts turn colder or demand surprise to the upside.
Outlook: Weather and diplomacy hold the key
The global gas market remains divided between a supply-constrained Europe and Asia, and a relatively well-supplied US market where speculative traders are betting heavily on a mild winter.
A diplomatic breakthrough in the Middle East could trigger a substantial correction in international gas prices, but a sustained decline will likely require both improving supply visibility and evidence that winter demand can be met without excessive storage withdrawals. In the US, meanwhile, the risk is increasingly one of short covering should the weather outlook turn less favourable for bearish positions.
| Related articles/content |
|---|
| 4 Nov 2026: US midterm shock Gold rallies copper reassesses tariffs as Trump faces gridlock 2 Nov 2026: Copper defies broader metals selloff as global supply tightness provides support 2 Nov 2026: Gold Short-term selling pressure tests longer-term conviction 2 Nov 2026: COT on forex and commodities - Week to 27 October 30 Oct 2026: Commodity weekly: October underscores a year of dramatic sector rotation 26 Oct 2026: COT on forex and commodities - Week to 20 Oct 2026 22 Oct 2026: Commodities caught between AI jitters and escalating energy risks Daily podcasts hosted by John J Hardy can be found here |
| More from the author |
|---|
|